Brussels Reporter
  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      The Swiss art of automata now part of…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

      Europe

      Coronavirus: Ultra-Orthodox Jews clash with Israeli police to…

      January 24, 2021January 25, 2021

      Europe

      Estonia to get new government, first female PM

      January 24, 2021

      Europe

      New Zealand records first COVID case outside of…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

      Europe

      Eleven workers rescued from China mine after being…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business

Brussels Reporter

  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      The Swiss art of automata now part of…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

      Europe

      Coronavirus: Ultra-Orthodox Jews clash with Israeli police to…

      January 24, 2021January 25, 2021

      Europe

      Estonia to get new government, first female PM

      January 24, 2021

      Europe

      New Zealand records first COVID case outside of…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

      Europe

      Eleven workers rescued from China mine after being…

      January 24, 2021January 24, 2021

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
Home Featured “We must fight climate change not merely as consumers, but as citizens” – panel discussion at Full Circle House
Featured

“We must fight climate change not merely as consumers, but as citizens” – panel discussion at Full Circle House

by editor March 31, 2019
March 31, 2019

A compelling discussion on climate migration took place on March 28th at Full Circle House, in the final session of the Brussels-based forum’s three-part series on borders and future migration.

The assembled panel, which consisted of an academic, an artist, and a professional activist, explored a number of different issues relating to climate change and migration flows. It was followed by an equally lively Q&A session with the audience.

The panel’s preliminary remarks

The first to speak was Alice Bell, a former historian of science and now Head of Communications at the UK-based climate charity 10:10. Dr Bell noted how, despite increasingly anomalous weather patterns and noticeable food price fluctuations in the West, it is still relatively easy – and common – for Westerners to “insulate” themselves from the worst effects of climate change. She went on to emphasise the need for citizens everywhere to work collectively to combat the significant threat that climate change now poses for the possibility of organised human existence. Moreover, she highlighted the importance of people around the world thinking of themselves as a collective, or, as she put it, “as globally-engaged citizens”.

 

Next to offer his remarks was Kooj Chuhan, a digital artist, filmmaker, and activist. Mr Chuhan stressed the need to overcome what he called “psychological distancing” among Western citizens. According to Mr Chuhan, this is the tendency among Westerners to regard people of the Global South – including, but not limited to, those most adversely affected by climate change – as unimportant, or indeed irrelevant, to their individual concerns. Mr Chuhan went on to remark upon psychological distancing’s relationship to geographical distance, claiming that the two often, if not invariably, correlate with one another. Lastly, he noted its historical connection to colonial discourse, in particular the Western tendency to ‘Other’ those suffering abuses for which we in the West are largely responsible.

The third and final panelist to comment was François Gemenne, a FNRS senior research associate at the University of Liège and a leading specialist in environmental geopolitics and migration dynamics. Two of Dr Gemenne’s remarks were particularly noteworthy. First, he pointed out that, although migrants have (rightly) received a large amount of recent media attention, and elicited a significant degree of sympathy and concern in the West, a sadly neglected class of individuals is the non-migrant: this is the person who is unable to leave his or her country of origin due to (e.g.) poverty, age, or lack of education. Dr Gemenne argued that the (climate) non-migrant is at least as deserving of the West’s sympathy and concern as the migrant is.

Second, Dr Gemenne argued forcefully that the categories used by Westerners to think about climate change and migration need to be reassessed. In particular, he claimed that the conceptual distinction between the “economic” and the “climate” migrant is largely a Western construct, which is not recognised by citizens of the Global South whose economic livelihood is often heavily, if not wholly, determined by climate fluctuations. Dr Gemenne also argued that we should regard climate change as a form of persecution toward the world’s most vulnerable citizens, and that “climate migrants” should (also) be regarded as economic migrants as well as political refugees, given that the majority of them leave their countries of origin as a result of Western policy decisions.

The Panellists (from left to right): Alice Bell, Kooj Chuhan, and François Gemenne

The Q&A

Further interesting questions and topics were raised by the panellists and members of the audience during the Q&A.

Dr Bell argued forcefully – and to the universal agreement of both the panelists and the audience – for lowering the voting age to 16, her reason being that it is young people who stand the most to gain, and lose, by contemporary climate-impacting policy decisions. Both Mr Chuhan and Dr Gemenne then emphasised the importance of education in climate activism, with Dr Gemenne in particular stressing the need for informing current policymakers rather than just young people. “We need to educate our 60 year olds, rather than just 16 year olds,” he said. “Otherwise, by the time the 16 year olds of today are in power, it might already be too late to save our planet.”

Dr Gemenne then went on to highlight the importance of fighting climate change not merely as a consumer, but as a citizen. “It is not one’s flights, or one’s car use, or the meals one eats that contribute to emissions,” he noted. “It’s the money in your bank account, invested by banks in fossil fuel companies in order to ensure high interest rates for depositors.” Dr Gemenne also argued that if we continue to think in terms of individual consumption behaviour as the sole means to effect climate action, it would be a “huge victory for neoliberalism”.

Finally, both Dr Gemenne and Mr Chuhan emphasised the need for pragmatism among climate activists. In particular, Dr Gemenne noted that, although the overthrowing of capitalism might perhaps be desirable in the long-run, activists must be realistic: the best chance of saving our planet, he argued, was to try to find a version of capitalism that is environmentally sustainable. “We need to make capitalism prioritise long-term, rather than short-term profits,” he said. This sentiment was echoed by Mr Chuhan’s own remarks about the need for “Hopeful Realism”, that is, a realism that “remains hopeful, but that doesn’t deny what needs to be done to affect positive change in the world”.

previous post
A standardised questionnaire to help those on long-term sick leave return to work
next post
Demonstration and traffic disruptions on Sunday 31 March 2019

Related Posts

Beat the winter blues – Brussels Express

February 10, 2019

Public debt drops to 86.1% of GDP in...

January 21, 2019

France wants to ‘move from brain death to...

November 24, 2019

Brexit Britain’s big talk on space fails to...

November 29, 2019

Will Janez Janša take Slovenia down the same...

October 28, 2020

The quest for EU passports: Brits leaving Brexit

January 30, 2019

'Yellow Vests' demonstrations: Foreign Affairs advises Belgians to...

December 13, 2018

British businesses “not made welcome” in Brussels after...

March 31, 2019

Coronavirus: Sweden’s Tegnell admits too many died

June 3, 2020

March against Marrakesh will go ahead despite ban

December 14, 2018
Promotion Image

Recent Posts

  • Sikkim: Chinese and Indian troops ‘in new border clash’
  • Heatwave sweeps Australian cities and raises bushfire danger
  • Russia Navalny protests: Kremlin hits out at West as it downplays rallies
  • The Swiss art of automata now part of UNESCO’s intangible heritage
  • Coronavirus: Ultra-Orthodox Jews clash with Israeli police to prevent closure of religious school
Promotion Image

GO!

Lifestyle

  • Scientists are using satellites to count elephants from space for the first time

  • France: Hospital workers demand more resources to fight COVID-19

  • Alexei Navalny: Millions watch jailed critic's 'Putin palace' film

  • Covid vaccine: WHO warns of ‘catastrophic moral failure’

  • Belgium looks good in white

Popular Posts

  • 1

    Beware of scammING. Dirty money of famous bank

    October 6, 2020
  • 2

    Norway: No link established after post-COVID-19 vaccination deaths, says health authority

    January 18, 2021
  • 3

    Assange fight draws in Trump’s new intel chief Ric Grenell

    February 25, 2020

Editor’s Choices

  • European Parliament will set up vaccination centers for MEPs, staff and locals

    January 21, 2021
  • Why ‘equal access’ to coronavirus vaccines is failing poor countries

    January 20, 2021
  • Merkel era may only just be beginning

    January 16, 2021

Opinions

  • Estonia to get new government, first female PM

    January 24, 2021
  • Russian police arrest over 1,300 at pro-Navalny protests

    January 23, 2021
  • Belgium clamps down on cross-border travel

    January 22, 2021

@2018-2021 - Brussels Reporter (www.brusselsreporter.com). All Right Reserved.