Brussels Reporter
  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      British citizens living abroad set to reclaim right…

      March 5, 2021March 6, 2021

      Europe

      Amazon directs customers to vaccine misinformation, study finds

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

      Europe

      US and EU suspend Airbus-Boeing tariffs for four…

      March 5, 2021

      Europe

      Dakar disorder after arrest of Senegal’s main opposition…

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

      Europe

      San Diego Zoo gives experimental COVID-19 vaccine to…

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business

Brussels Reporter

  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      British citizens living abroad set to reclaim right…

      March 5, 2021March 6, 2021

      Europe

      Amazon directs customers to vaccine misinformation, study finds

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

      Europe

      US and EU suspend Airbus-Boeing tariffs for four…

      March 5, 2021

      Europe

      Dakar disorder after arrest of Senegal’s main opposition…

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

      Europe

      San Diego Zoo gives experimental COVID-19 vaccine to…

      March 5, 2021March 5, 2021

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
Home Europe The not-so-secret sex lives of French politicians
EuropeFeatured

The not-so-secret sex lives of French politicians

by editor February 18, 2020
February 18, 2020

John Lichfield is a former foreign editor of the Independent and was the newspaper’s Paris correspondent for 20 years.

PARIS — France feels violated. Or rather, part of France feels violated: political France, Parisian France, mainstream media France.

For the first time in the country’s modern history, a politician has resigned because his sex life — his private, consensual sex life — has been publicly exposed. Literally exposed, in this case.

Benjamin Griveaux, French President Emmanuel Macron’s candidate to become mayor of Paris next month, stepped down last Friday. A video of him masturbating, which he sent to a 27-year-old woman two years ago, had been posted online.

Politicians and commentators of all stripes, from hard left to far right, were outraged — not by Griveaux’s behavior but by the posting of the video and the fact that it had caused him to resign.

“We are not electing a saint but the mayor of Paris” — Sébastien Chenu of the far-right National Rally party

They complained that France’s relaxed and sane attitude to the sex lives of politicians had been overwhelmed by the crude “gotcha” values of social media and the internet.

French public life was being “Americanized,” they said. A vital barrier between politics and sex, the public and the private, had fallen. At stake was nothing less than the future of French democracy.

Sébastien Chenu of the far-right National Rally party said, “We are not electing a saint but the mayor of Paris.”

Richard Ferrand, the president of the National Assembly, a friend of Griveaux and a prominent Macronite, weighed in from another band of the political spectrum: “Everyone has their right to a ‘secret garden’ — a privacy of thought and action,” he said. “Don’t let’s muddle transparency and voyeurism, a step towards a kind of sexual inquisition.”

Former French President Jacques Chirac | Patrick Kovarik/AFP via Getty Images

After 23 years in France, I confess that I find myself confused. I thought that I understood France pretty well. I realize that I don’t.

The reaction to the Griveaux affair — or “Masturgate” — appears to me to be at once predictable, understandable and absurd.

The invasion of private lives of private citizens is wrong and often cruel. You only need to look at the British tabloid media to see how wrong and cruel it can be.

Is it equally wrong to discuss — within reason — the private lives and hypocrisies of public figures?

Griveaux, married with three small children, boasted in his campaign about his happy family life and conservative values. Former President Jacques Chirac and many other conservative French politicians have been guilty of similar double standards in the past.

Perhaps more to the point, this was not simply an extramarital affair. Griveaux sent a young woman, a law student at the time, a video of himself masturbating. He was then, in May 2018, a Cabinet minister and chief spokesman for the government.

Hervé Gattagno, editor of Le Journal du Dimanche, wrote that Griveaux was “irresponsible but not guilty.”

That seems to me to reveal something important about Griveaux’s character and maturity and fitness for office. According to most French commentators, that is an obdurately Anglo-Saxon and prudish attitude.

The nearest to criticism of Griveaux that you can find in the French media has come from Hervé Gattagno, editor of Le Journal du Dimanche. He wrote, wittily, that Griveaux was “irresponsible but not guilty.”

The case is further complicated by the extraordinary saga of how the video came to be posted online. The woman to whom Griveaux sent the images in May 2008, Alexandra de Taddeo, is now a lawyer. She’s also a hard-left political activist, as is her new lover, an exiled Russian, anarchist and performance artist, Piotr Pavlenski, who once nailed his scrotum to Red Square.

It was Pavlenski, now close to the Yellow Jackets movement, who put the video online last week after failing to interest the French investigative website Mediapart. Like the satirical weeky, Le Canard Enchainé, Mediapart refuses to touch revelations of a private, sexual nature.

Griveaux sent the images to De Taddeo two years ago using an app that was supposed to obliterate them after a few minutes. Instead, they were somehow recorded — or recovered. Was this a long-planned political hit job?

That remains unclear. It seems to me unlikely. Why hold on to the images for so long?

Former IMF chief Dominique Strauss-Kahn | Philippe Huguen/AFP via Getty Images

Both De Taddeo and Pavlenksi were arrested last Saturday and face possible charges of “invasion of private life” and “posting unauthorized sexual images.”

Long-planned or not, the posting of the images was clearly part of a war on Macron and his allies that is being waged ceaselessly on the internet by both the far left and far right. Other ammunition used in that war includes misrepresentations and outright lies about Macron’s policies — and baseless rumors about the president’s own private life.

To that extent, the fears of French mainstream media are justified. De Taddeo and Pavlenski’s behavior is part of a deliberate assault on representative democracy — a systematic attempt to sully all mainstream politicians and the mainstream media.

Does that excuse Griveaux? To the obdurate Anglo-Saxon in me, it suggests that his behavior was even more stupid and unforgiveable.

In any case, the shriek of rage about the violation of the French law and taboo on personal privacy is itself hypocritical. French glossy magazines invade the privacy of foreign royalty and domestic and foreign showbiz celebs weekly — and pay up the moderate fines as part of their business model. No one much protests.

By my own observation, French people outside the Paris bubble are not so enthusiastic as insiders about the immunity of politicians’ private lives. The original Yellow Jackets movement was driven in part by lurid fantasies of taxpayer-funded orgies — symptomatic of a wider sense of being denied the whole truth.

The lesson for French politicians from Griveaux’s troubles is more subtle than it seems.

The Dominique Strauss-Kahn affair in 2012 should have buried once and for all the notion that wayward sexual behavior by French male politicians can be a matter of private gossip, but not public concern. DSK’s reputation as someone who pushed behavior with women to the limit was well known. No one wrote about it, with one honorable (or, to French eyes, dishonorable) exception.

That kind of immunity can no longer exist in the internet age. French law, and media self-denying ordonnances, might keep discussion of the sex lives of politicians out of mainstream publications or platforms. Extending that prohibition to the darker reaches of the net is impossible.

The lesson for French politicians from Griveaux’s troubles is more subtle than it seems. If the French politician had “merely” had an affair with a consenting 27-year-old student, the story would have been a one-day wonder, if that. It’s the video that made the difference.

French politicians do not have to behave like saints. But they should avoid acting like the most idiotic of teenagers.

Source link

previous post
First ‘misfit’ to join UK government resigns over alleged racism
next post
A democratic and civic opportunity we cannot afford to miss – VoxEurop (English)

Related Posts

What’s going on with abstention in Europe?

May 22, 2019

Austrian foreign ministry under ‘serious cyberattack’

January 5, 2020

Catalonia confines 200,000 residents amid spike in coronavirus...

July 4, 2020

Sister of Italy

March 13, 2020

Mum fearful for her son’s life after Brexit...

January 7, 2021

Europe must find the antidote for Viktor Orbán’s...

April 20, 2020

French PM announces move to delay regional elections

November 13, 2020

Summer was hottest on record in Northern Hemisphere

September 14, 2020

France: Thousands protest virus restrictions on cultural sector

December 16, 2020

Pablo Hasel: Clashes at more Spain protests in...

February 17, 2021
Promotion Image

Recent Posts

  • Pope Francis meets powerful Shia cleric in Iraq
  • Amanpour: Harry and Megan Oprah interview ‘won’t be an easy ride’
  • British citizens living abroad set to reclaim right to vote in UK elections
  • Amazon directs customers to vaccine misinformation, study finds
  • Picnic time! Belgium begins easing coronavirus restrictions
Promotion Image

GO!

Lifestyle

  • Scientists are using satellites to count elephants from space for the first time

  • France: Hospital workers demand more resources to fight COVID-19

  • Alexei Navalny: Millions watch jailed critic's 'Putin palace' film

  • Covid vaccine: WHO warns of ‘catastrophic moral failure’

  • Belgium looks good in white

Popular Posts

  • 1

    Post-Brexit talks: A chink of light at the end of the UK-EU trade tunnel?

    July 27, 2020
  • 2

    San Diego Zoo gives experimental COVID-19 vaccine to 9 great apes

    March 5, 2021
  • 3

    At least 6 people killed in shooting at Czech teaching hospital

    December 10, 2019

Editor’s Choices

  • European Parliament will set up vaccination centers for MEPs, staff and locals

    January 21, 2021
  • Why ‘equal access’ to coronavirus vaccines is failing poor countries

    January 20, 2021
  • Merkel era may only just be beginning

    January 16, 2021

Opinions

  • Picnic time! Belgium begins easing coronavirus restrictions

    March 5, 2021
  • US and EU suspend Airbus-Boeing tariffs for four months

    March 5, 2021
  • UK’s new Brexit man makes his mark with Northern Ireland row

    March 4, 2021

@2018-2021 - Brussels Reporter (www.brusselsreporter.com). All Right Reserved.