Brussels Reporter
  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      Greece will raise pensions in 2023, says PM…

      July 7, 2022July 7, 2022

      Europe

      Spanish foreign minister presses EU to retrain focus…

      July 7, 2022

      Europe

      British government says ‘no’ to Scotland on new…

      July 6, 2022July 7, 2022

      Europe

      Women’s Euro 2022 tournament kicks off in England

      July 6, 2022July 6, 2022

      Europe

      Dozens of police injured as EU compromise protest…

      July 6, 2022July 6, 2022

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business

Brussels Reporter

  • Home
  • Brussels
  • Europe
    • Europe

      Greece will raise pensions in 2023, says PM…

      July 7, 2022July 7, 2022

      Europe

      Spanish foreign minister presses EU to retrain focus…

      July 7, 2022

      Europe

      British government says ‘no’ to Scotland on new…

      July 6, 2022July 7, 2022

      Europe

      Women’s Euro 2022 tournament kicks off in England

      July 6, 2022July 6, 2022

      Europe

      Dozens of police injured as EU compromise protest…

      July 6, 2022July 6, 2022

  • Globe
  • Lifestyle
  • Business
Home Europe 5 takeaways from Nicola Sturgeon’s evidence in Salmond probe
EuropeFeatured

5 takeaways from Nicola Sturgeon’s evidence in Salmond probe

by editor March 3, 2021
March 3, 2021

GLASGOW — The political vultures were circling Nicola Sturgeon on Wednesday — but Scotland’s first minister wasn’t going to give them an easy meal.

Against a chorus of resignation cries, her message to a parliamentary committee investigating government malpractice was clear: mistakes were made, but I’ve got nothing to hide. 

There was no conspiracy against her predecessor Alex Salmond, Sturgeon asserted, appearing before a marathon all-day session of an inquiry into the mishandling of sexual harassment claims leveled at Scotland’s former leader (for which he was subsequently acquitted in court). Her government didn’t wilfully waste half-a-million pounds of public money fighting a doomed legal case against her onetime mentor, Sturgeon added; nor did she mislead parliament about the affair’s finer details. She is, in her own mind, innocent of all charges.

The opposition disagrees. Lawmakers were uncompromising — and seemingly unconvinced — in the oral evidence session, and the threat of a confidence vote still hangs over Sturgeon’s head. More importantly, however, the Scottish National Party (SNP) and its campaign for independence remains riven by a dispute that shows no sign of abating. 

Here are five takeaways from Sturgeon’s committee appearance: 

1. No conspiracy

“I want to take this opportunity to say sorry,” Sturgeon said this morning, her voice charged with emotion. Sorry to the women let down by a bungled investigation into abuse allegations; sorry to the taxpayer whose money was lost on a mishandled court case. But for Salmond, who last year was cleared of all harassment charges, there was no apology. 

Instead, the first minister rubbished his “absurd” claim that she and others had conspired to ruin his reputation in an effort to banish him from public life. 

“Alex Salmond has been for most of my life — since I was about 20, 21 years old — not just a very close political colleague,” Sturgeon said, but “a friend, someone in my younger days who I looked up to and revered … I had no motive, intention, desire to get [him].”

True or not, the pair’s acrimonious split has cleaved their party in two. As Sturgeon issued her opening remarks, #IStandWithNicola spread as an online rallying cry for supportive colleagues. Today, their voice was the loudest — but Salmond loyalists fill party ranks and are a group both beholden to their former leader and skeptical of Sturgeon’s stewardship of the independence campaign. 

2. Sturgeon knew what, when?

At the very heart of the controversy is precisely when Sturgeon learnt of the allegations against her former boss. That may seem an inconsequential detail, but political opponents — and Salmond — say Sturgeon misled parliament with the timeframe she provided. 

The first minister told lawmakers it was during a meeting at her home in April 2018 that she was notified of the harassment accusations, though it is claimed she was in fact told days earlier by Salmond’s chief of staff, Geoff Aberdein. 

“My recollection [of the earlier meeting] is still not as vivid as I would like it to be,” Sturgeon said Wednesday; an explanation that raised eyebrows on the parliamentary panel given the nature of the information that was imparted to the first minister.  

This matters because, if proven to have misled the inquiry, Sturgeon would be in breach of her government’s ministerial code, meaning she would be expected to resign.

The first minister vociferously denies any wrongdoing and awaits the findings of an adjacent investigation into the specific allegation. 

3. Doomed court case 

In late 2018, the Scottish government pushed on with an ill-fated (and expensive) court case against Salmond, though defeat was all-but-certain. Why? On Wednesday, Sturgeon set out to provide an answer.

Yes, her side’s argument was seriously hampered by the fact officials had had prior contact with complainants, and yes, government lawyers shared huge doubts about victory a full three months before concession. But the case was winnable until the 11th hour, Sturgeon maintained; and so the cost of defeat — £500,000 of public money — must be taken on the chin. 

That’s a difficult pill to swallow, but not, the first minister argued, tantamount to a breach of the ministerial code, as her predecessor suggested last week. And of the claims that she allowed the doomed civil proceedings to persist in the hope that they would, before long, be eclipsed by Salmond’s criminal case? “Absurd and bizarre, and just completely without any evidential or factual foundation,” Sturgeon said. 

4. Who’s leaking?

In an apparent breach of data protection laws, the name of one of Salmond’s accusers was passed by a senior official to his team — or so the former first minister claims.

Sturgeon and the Scottish government have long disputed this, but on Tuesday night, two individuals close to Salmond — his lawyer and a former adviser — caused shockwaves by publicly corroborating the charge. The reaction was volcanic, with immediate calls for Sturgeon to resign. 

Challenged on the issue, she said this new evidence amounted to hearsay, and that her predecessor likely learned the claimant’s identity by trawling through government social media feeds pertaining to the day of the alleged incident.   

Whether that defence will hold up to further scrutiny, only time will tell, but it’s not the only leaking allegation. Last week, Salmond called for a police investigation into the disclosure of complaints against him to the press — a politically motivated move, he claimed. 

“I don’t know where the leaks came from. I can tell you where I know they didn’t come from, they didn’t come from me, they didn’t come from anybody acting on my authority,” Sturgeon said.

5. This ain’t over

With May’s pivotal Scottish parliament election fast approaching, the SNP is desperate to put the Salmond debacle to bed. After Wednesday’s fireworks, that’s not going to happen.

With Sturgeon on the ropes, opposition leaders are desperate to dent her towering popularity before voters go to the polls. Some — namely Scottish Conservative leader Douglas Ross — want to go further, calling for a vote of no confidence in the first minister. 

Whether the numbers are there for that to pass isn’t clear, but the reputational harm could sting Sturgeon regardless. She is trying to sell the Scottish people on independence, a decision of unparalleled historic significance. That requires public trust — something the SNP will worry is now ebbing away.

Source link

previous post
ICC opens 'war crimes' investigation in West Bank and Gaza
next post
Then and now: A ‘megadrought’ in California

Related Posts

‘No evidence’ that COVID-19 plasma treatment approved by...

August 25, 2020

Europe’s QAnon followers embrace US election conspiracy theories

November 6, 2020

Belarus leader warns of ‘harsh sanctions’ against opposition...

August 4, 2020

Brisbane to host the 2032 Olympic Games

July 21, 2021

Dublin streets quiet on second day of Ireland’s...

October 26, 2020

The truth is out there: The Milky Way...

June 16, 2020

Massive fire at paint factory in Gaza

May 18, 2021

Canada’s early election produces almost no change as...

September 21, 2021

Spanish Parliament begins debate on ‘Only Yes is...

October 15, 2021

EU sanctions Russian hackers for 2015 Bundestag breach

October 22, 2020
Promotion Image

Recent Posts

  • Greece will raise pensions in 2023, says PM Mitsotakis, for first time in more than a decade
  • Georgia Guidestones: 'America's Stonehenge' demolished after blast
  • Spanish foreign minister presses EU to retrain focus on migration
  • Refugee Diaries: Images of home, old and new
  • How TikTok is fuelling dreams of wealth in the Arab world
Promotion Image

GO!

Lifestyle

  • Scientists are using satellites to count elephants from space for the first time

  • France: Hospital workers demand more resources to fight COVID-19

  • Alexei Navalny: Millions watch jailed critic's 'Putin palace' film

  • Covid vaccine: WHO warns of ‘catastrophic moral failure’

  • Belgium looks good in white

Popular Posts

  • 1

    Ukraine invasion: Fighting breaks out in Ukraine's second city Kharkiv

    February 27, 2022
  • 2

    Ukraine war: Putin will be held responsible for shopping centre ‘war crime’, say G7 leaders

    June 28, 2022
  • 3

    South Africa police try to unravel tavern deaths tragedy

    June 27, 2022

Editor’s Choices

  • Sociopath ING or a blockchain of corruption from a well-known financial group

    May 24, 2021
  • Pfizer, AstraZeneca COVID jabs ‘highly effective’ against India variant, study shows

    May 23, 2021
  • G20 leaders at Rome summit pledge more vaccines for poorer countries

    May 21, 2021

Opinions

  • Spanish foreign minister presses EU to retrain focus on migration

    July 7, 2022
  • Refugee Diaries: Images of home, old and new

    July 7, 2022
  • Belgium green-lights treaty that would allow convicted terrorist to be sent back to Iran

    July 6, 2022

@2018-2021 - Brussels Reporter (www.brusselsreporter.com). All Right Reserved.